Umfrage #1331832
Make my decisions for me.
Open to: Alle, detailed results viewable to: Alle, participants: 8
I am equally good at both and enjoy both equally. The teaching is more consistent for German - most of the teachers suck equally - whereas one of the teachers I know for History is REALLY GOOD but boring, and the other has been rubbish all through lower school, but is apparently good for A-level.
I am already planning on taking Maths, Chemistry, Physics and Further Maths, so I want something that I can take and do the AS before dropping it at the end of Y12. German might be better for that, and it has the advantage that I want to be fluent in German, and have native German speakers in my family. However, I am also excessively good at History (full marks in all my coursework so far) and I love that, and can manage it on my own.
In short, both of them are good ideas. Disadvantages - German has a speaking element which I have problems with, and I think for History you have to study the Tudors for part of it, which I hate. But you also get to do the Russian Revolution, I think, and the unification of Germany, which I love... but I really want to speak fluent German, and I may do a degree with a year in continental Europe, where it'd come in handy, and... too many decisions.
Open to: Alle, detailed results viewable to: Alle, participants: 8
Do I take History or German?
I am equally good at both and enjoy both equally. The teaching is more consistent for German - most of the teachers suck equally - whereas one of the teachers I know for History is REALLY GOOD but boring, and the other has been rubbish all through lower school, but is apparently good for A-level.
I am already planning on taking Maths, Chemistry, Physics and Further Maths, so I want something that I can take and do the AS before dropping it at the end of Y12. German might be better for that, and it has the advantage that I want to be fluent in German, and have native German speakers in my family. However, I am also excessively good at History (full marks in all my coursework so far) and I love that, and can manage it on my own.
In short, both of them are good ideas. Disadvantages - German has a speaking element which I have problems with, and I think for History you have to study the Tudors for part of it, which I hate. But you also get to do the Russian Revolution, I think, and the unification of Germany, which I love... but I really want to speak fluent German, and I may do a degree with a year in continental Europe, where it'd come in handy, and... too many decisions.
- Wo bin ich?:Yorkshire, UK
- Wie fühle ich?:
tired


Comments
German is more win, and I can teach you the parts of the RR I learn in college. If I get into college :P
I HATE THE TUDORS SO SO MUCH. SRSLY. HATE HATE HAT! I have no words for it! They're just annoying, and upper-class.
You can! I already know a lot about Lenin and the 1917 Crew, but it'd be kinda cool to study it in-depth. I think I'll find out more about the History course before I make my decision.
And, of course you'll get into college :) You have awesome grades - they won't turn you down. I'm having to do interviews and applications for my own sixth form, and it's hell D:
But.... Tudors.... D:
I actually picked my colleges based on the content of their History courses. I can't stand the old system of like, monarchs and lords and stuff, and the IR is a bit boring.
My grades is not awesome. Srsly.
I know... I hate the Tudors... D:
I can't stand upper-class or middle-class history. Not at all. And anything before about 1850 turns me off - it's not personally relevant to me. I like the 20th century, really. If I was thinking of taking history further, and I had a choice of colleges (I don't) I'd have done the same.
As and A*s, amirite? Way better than those around you.
They suck. I wouldn't take it. Seriously, it's bad.
Meh.
They suck hard. And if you wouldn't take it, I think that's good enough for me. I'm still gonna go and find out what the course consists of, though.
IT'S THE FUCKING AWFUL TUDORS!
Also, I am planning on using German in my degree, that's the problem. Imperial College does physics with a year in continental Europe, which I'm seriously considering, as well as the possibility of taking languages credits with a main physics or maths degree, or moving to Germany once I've done my initial degree.
Meh, it's your choice. You asked, I'm merely giving you my opinion and recommendation; don't have a go at me if I give you an answer you have evidently already discounted.
Actually, I've not discounted it at all; I was leaning much more in the direction of history until a few hours ago. I'm disagreeing with your opinion so I can test it out and see if arguing against it holds water, in which case I won't take it.
(Aus offensichtlichen Gründen. Außerdem werde ich nie wieder jemandem zu Geschichte raten, weil ich es selbst sehr hasse, seit ich es als Hauptfach habe.)
(Warum hast du es als Hauptfach gewählt, wenn du es hasst? Oder darfst du nicht wählen?)
Allerdings wüsste ich auch nicht, was ich sonst hätte wählen sollen. Da meine anderen Hauptfächer Englisch und Deutsch sind, hätte ich entweder eine andere Gemeinschaftskunde (Sozialkunde oder Erdkunde) oder eine Naturwissenschaft (Biologie, Phyik oder Chemie) wählen können. Darin bin ich allerdings noch schlechter als in Geschichte :D
Ich würde Physik, Mathe und Deutsch wählen, wenn ich nur drei Fächer lernen könnte. Glücklicherweise haben Englische Studenten mehr Optionen, und normalerweise man studiert drei oder vier Fächer vor man in die Uni geht, aber ich könnte nicht wählen und werde fünf lernen :) Mathe, Chemie, Physik, hoffentlich Deutsch, und Further Maths (ich weiss nicht, wenn es ein deutsches Äquivalent gibt, aber es ist Mathe mit addiertem Mathe :P) Ich denke, dass ich nicht anfangen darf, Mathe langweilig zu finden...
Ich beneide und bewundere dich dafür, dass du Physik und Chemie verstehst. Chemie habe nicht (zum Glück!) nicht mehr, aber als ich es noch hatte war es mein schlechtestes Fach. In Physik verstehe ich meistens nichts :D
Allerdings habe ich in Mathe zum Glück seinen sehr guten Lehrer, der alles geduldig erklärt, sodass ich eine der besten Schülerinnen in meinem Kurs bin :)
Their entire AS is Henry VIII and the Holocaust (no not as in the effect of the former on the latter, although that could be interesting... *must stop going off on historical tangents*).
Dull much? Yes they have in fact taken the two worst bits of the course and scrapped the rest, so you get loads of depth but no breadth. The staff are quite annoyed about it as well, as it was essentially sprung on them, and it bears no resemblance to uni history. SRSLY they're not even doing the Berlin trip anymore after ours because there's no point! At least there won't be all those people who only took it for the trip coughnotmeatallevercough.
The languages courses however have also been made less fun, imho, what with the scrapping of coursework (which would have been your major chance to get the history in there) and putting listening, reading and writing all in one paper. But Sarah's probably the one to discuss this part with.
I really do think you'd be better off with German from a future-ish p.o.v what with years abroad etc (though I think you'll be ok from GCSE on that score, they'll just give you more language tuition). Having said that, one of my friends did what you're planning but with history (try and find him in your 6th form prospectus if you have one lol) and loved it, having been dubious before.
Anyway, I know you'll just do which you like so this was all of course pointless :P
You can tell i'm avoiding revision can't you?
No coursework? *blinks* ... NO COURSEWORK? LULZ WUT. But I like languages coursework. Oh man oh man oh man. That is penis, on a plate. Ugh. *shudder* BOTH sound bad.
Is your friend the one who's going to do maths or something at Cambridge? Mrs Brooke said I should talk to him, as apparently I would learn things :P Is he the one who explained imaginary numbers to me?
Oh forgot before, in history you get to do a Personal Study on whatever you like (srsly at all ever), so you could do your Bismarck there, but I have a sneaking suspiscion you'd have to do it about Britain in your course :(
Yes he is, maths and physics - you should definitely speak to him, you WOULD learn a lot (he's like rob, only less clever-by-accident if you get me). Although you'd never agree politically.
Or you could just do AS further maths, either way...
But yes, we applied to the same college too :(
No, not him, someone else. Andrew (imaginary numbers) is reasonably similar, but a bit less clever and more stereotypical geek.
Would you like to hear an amusing story about me and Josh? (Aforementioned mathematician, not bassoonist)
No, not like that *rolls eyes*
I texted you btw
I should speak to him, then! Damn that we'd never agree politically - it sucks that intelligent people can have stupid views. I'm doing AS further maths anyway (dear, I want to get onto a physics degree or a maths degree, it's relatively necessary :P) but apparently he'd... be useful to talk to, according to her, and she's the one teacher whose opinion I listen to.
I would, actually! Is he the gay one, or have I got them confused? I also know you texted, but I'm down to my last 9p of credit and so cannot reply. I am very glad of the personal interest you're taking in my prom dress :P I think I'll get myself down to Debenhams and have a look, basically. Or get on the website first, and have a look for that one you said about, but I'd need to try it on to make sure I didn't look too obscene. Thankyou very much :)
Sarah and Hannah (Jevons) vote German, too btw
*Thinks of occasion you would actually meet* Damn your y11-and-hence-lack-of-free-periods-ness!
Well, he was brought up Tory and doesn't seem to have rescinded the view, however he has no issues with Pete and afaik Laura&Kathryn, Edward's ideas put him in the shade, and he's thankfully not religious; so you know...
Oh, re: further maths, check in your prospectus thing/ with Mrs Brook(e?) as to what modules you'd be doing - our year did Decision 1 and 2 in y12, neither of which are accepted by Cambridge, among other unis, so you may need to go down the Josh route of teaching yourself extra modules to replace them :/
Or go down the Emma route and hold off F.M until y13 when you can pick your modules :)
No, Pete is the gay one (as referenced above). I should do a chart of all my male friends so my friends in other years know who they are lol
I can't remember what the anecdote was, so I'll tell you the (slightly embarrassing(for him)) story of Josh's love life:
Josh spends much of his spare time on facebook;
here he looks up girls who generally live in the ne area, but not close by;
after a while, he will start to refer to her as his girlfriend
sometimes he will arranged to meet the girl (this leads to much speculation among the other boys as to whether she is actually a 40yr old man),
however this will rarely go ahead due to: impracticalities re: distance; her being involved w/ someone else closer to home (ie whom she's actually seen) etc etc.
Srsly, I once spent an afternoon on the net for him looking up trains to conisbrough (where he never actually ended up going).
I is Good Friend!
Oh, i remembered the anecdote - it was about a box of cointreau chocolates, and you really had to be there
Has also realised that you really don't need telling of the pitfalls of ldrs, but hey
Languages, however, are a bit of a doss. And I study them at university so this isn't just a random disparaging comment (NB, they're hard AS at Cambridge :P) (if you think hard enough and paid any attention to nagty people then you might be able to work out who I am, lol). At A level, they are absolute piss - the lightest workload of them all. Conversation's a bitch, I agree, but it's all practice. And you get a useful skill for much less effort than History, which really does eat your life up.
On a side note - a classist historian? Interesting. I personally enjoy studying viewpoints that I completely disagree with, but maybe that's my perverse academically masochistic side coming out :P
If there's less work, then again, that's a massive plus - I'll be taking 5 AS, so I want as small a workload as is possible within that. I know the course we do has no coursework (which kinda annoys me, really - I'm good at languages coursework) which has to help. Dosses are always awesome :) (In terms of the Big Mystery of who you are, I'd imagine you're... damn, I can't remember your name - Zoe, maybe - but, the person who went to do Spanish at Uni.)
I like to study viewpoints that I disagree with totally, yeah, but I don't like to study issues that I disagree with totally. I mean... I wouldn't mind covering, say, the views of those who thought the New Deal was excessively socialist and government intervention is a DREADFUL thing, but I would really dislike doing a whole module on the evolution of capitalism through the 19th century, to pick an example out of thin air. Actually, that might be kinda interesting. I mean... *shrugs* I don't know exactly what I mean. Some things just turn me off, and studying royalty is one of them.
And yeah, that is me. Go me :) And it was Spanish and Russian, for some godforsaken reason.
And I suppose I can see your point. Although I still loved studying the roots of the Tories and all that, despite being desperately un-Conservative. And I did a whole personal study on religion in politics, despite being agnostic. But maybe I'm just strange - I enjoy studying the other side mostly so I can rip it apart :P